“Daylight Saving Time: Only the government would believe that you could cut a foot off the top of a blanket, sew it to the bottom, and have a longer blanket.” – Unknown Native American
First, a bit of history about Daylight Saving Time (DST, aka “summer time”). First suggested by Benjamin Frankline in a 1784 satirical letter addressed to the Paris City Council showing how it could save oodles of money on candles and gas lights by adding an hour of daylight in the evening. (Ben himself usually slept until noon in France.) In 1895 a New Zealander bug collector suggested it so he could collect more bugs in the evening after work. In 1907 a British golfer proposed DST to give him another hour in the evening to play his favorite game. In 1916 the German government adopted DST two years after starting WWI. In 1918 United States Congress adopted DST. This federal law was repealed in 1919, with help from the farmers’ lobby and only over two vetoes of the repeal by President Wilson, an avid golfer.
Year-round DST (“War Time”) was reinstated 1945-1947 to reserve resources (coal for electricity mostly) during WWII. In 1973 the oil crisis caused the return of nation-wide permanent DST. It was repealed a year later due to the disapproval of families who disliked their children going to school in the morning darkness of winter. (A subsequent study in 2025 estimated that permanent DST which delays winter sunrises by one hour would result in 2 billion more commutes in the dark by U.S. school children.)
The federal Sunshine Protection Act of of March 2022 proposing permanent DST passed the Senate unanimously. The House did not vote on it, and it expired at the end of the congressional session. Reintroduced versions of permanent DST have not advanced.
19 states implement seasonal DST today. (Arizona and Hawaii – do not DST 2026) The media discussions of DST did provide a brief respite from polarized political reporting during the recent mid-term elections.
MYTHS of DST
1.“It saves electricity by prolonging daylight” (Ben’s orginal thesis)
A study in 2020 indicated that only 6% of U.S. electricity was used after sunset. A 2024 follow-up meta analysis (a review of multiple published scientific studies) showed that DST caused only 0.3% of electricity saving in a 24 hour day.
2. “Farmers like it because it gives them an extra hour of daylight to work”
WRONG. DST has been consistently opposed by farmers, mostly because the cows, who can’t tell time, stay on solartime (ST) and the farmer already gets up very early in the morning; “Why make us get up an hour earlier in the fall?”. The Vermont cow population (can’t tell time, nor vote) has decreased by 82% while Vermont people (many of which can vote) has increased by 80% since 1930.
3. “Increases production”
WRONG again . . .at least for the “Spring ahead” switch. On the Monday after DST begins cybersurfing at work increases and work absences increase. A contested 2000 study suggested that switching to DST “caused” a one day loss of $31 billion in stock exchanges. Negative effects have not been seen after the “fall back” switch as DST ends. An “extra hour of sleep” is apparently an easier adjustment to make as “the sun rises an hour later”. No positive effects of the fall switch have been found either.
Much of the fuss about DST is based on the switching of time. Ignoring for the moment the political and special interest arguments, what are the physiological effects of the time switches from Standard Time (or Solar Time which directs our circadian rhythms ) to DST which is an arbitrary, human time-clock change ?Initially after the Spring switch to DST: incidence of heart attacks increase by 24% (especially for those over 60 yo.), strokes up 8%, increased mood disturbances due to decreased frontal lobe control, and 6% rise in fatal traffic accidents (particularly of pedestrians); ALL assumed to be because of loss of sleep. These effects lessen gradually over the next for 5-6 days.
A 2025 Stanford study compared the year-long circadian health impact of permanent Standard Time, permanent Daylight Saving Time, and biannually switching in the continental US using models of the human circadian rhythm and CDC health data. Researchers found that switching to permanent Standard Time was predicted to reduce cases of obesity by 2.6 million cases (more physical activity in the evening) and stroke by 300,000 cases. Permanent Daylight Saving Time also reduced cases but to a lesser extent. In interviews, the authors caution that this work is from a circadian health perspective and that other factors should be considered in policy decisions such as economic and safety impacts of time policy.
The setting of the sun [ST] is in conflict with the clock on the wall [DST], explained Sabra Abbott, MD, PhD, an associate professor of neurology at the Northwestern University Feinberg School of Medicine; “You’re dealing with this arbitrary clock that’s telling you it’s a different time than what your body thinks it is.” The American Academy of Sleep Medicine (AASM) has formally called for the elimination of seasonal clock changes, recommending permanent standard time as the healthier option, since it better aligns with natural circadian rhythms.
|
Factor |
Effect of DST |
Evidence Strength |
|
Evening daylight |
More outdoor time, retail activity |
Strong |
|
Energy savings |
Small lighting reduction, offset by heating/cooling |
Mixed |
|
Heart attacks (spring) |
Temporary increase |
Strong |
|
Sleep disruption |
2–5 days adjustment after each transition |
Strong |
|
Traffic safety |
Net effect small and debated |
Mixed |
|
Crime |
Modest reduction in evening crime |
Moderate |
|
Agriculture |
Generally negative (schedule disruption) |
Historical |
https://www.daylightsavingtime.info/dst-pros-cons
So. if “permanent DST” is a 2028 ballot question, your vote might depend on whether you are a milk farmer, a single parent with two elementary school children, a 65yo. woman with heart disease, a golfer. a bug collector, a stock broker, a person on the brink of depression, . . . . or one already depressed. But in fact, if there were no sun, and therefore no solar time, DST switching would, of course, become moot in the face of our innate circadian rhythm of 48 hours , as proven by the researcher who spent months in a dark cave without a clock, in both France and Texas! (Potential apocalyptic science fiction authors please take note.)
